Yahoo奇摩知識+將於 2021 年 5 月 4 日 (美國東部時間) 終止服務。自 2021 年 4 月 20 日 (美國東部時間) 起,Yahoo奇摩知識+服務將會轉為唯讀模式。其他Yahoo奇摩產品與服務或您的Yahoo奇摩帳號都不會受影響。如需關於Yahoo奇摩知識+ 停止服務以及下載您個人資料的資訊,請參閱說明網頁。

PJH 發問時間: Science & MathematicsAstronomy & Space · 10 年前

What really is the speed of light?

It is said that the light of sun takes about 8 minutes to reach earth:

http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/question.php?numb...

This means that for light to reach sun from earth it should take about the same time. But is that really true? Shouldn't the time needed be zero and instantaneous? Think about it..., if there is a lamp as big as the earth or bigger than the sun located at earth and points toward the sun, if you switch it on, isn't it obvious that it takes no time for the light of that lamp to hit the sun? Plus one can also simulate this on a desk in your room - make a miniature model of sun and one for earth that is equivalent to real life ratio and place them in a way in which the distance between these two models is also identical to the ratio of real life. Now place a flashlight at the location of the little earth and point it directly at the sun model, then switch it on, isn't it obvious it takes no time for that light to reach the sun? Is it possible that the scientific finding about speed of light is wrong...? Now lets say the size of the source of light is not that crazily big but real life and small. If it does take 8 minutes for light to reach sun from earth from that flashlight in your hand as you stand outside during the day and point the flashlight directly at the sun in the sky, while it takes no time for light of a light source that is humongous to travel from earth to sun, does this imply that speed of light varies with the size of the light source? That the bigger the light source the faster its light travels?

6 個解答

最相關
  • 匿名使用者
    10 年前
    最佳解答

    best trolling ever. I can't believe these people even bothered to answer.

    You, Sir, are a genius!

  • 匿名使用者
    10 年前

    Speed of Light has no relation with size of the source.

    When you see a light coming from sun, then it is the light which is 8 min older.

    As the speed of the light is 299,792,458m/s and the distance between sun and earth is 149,598,000 km. So we cannot see the difference of 8 min as the source is constantly sending light to Earth.

    Imagine that a sun emits light at 5:52 AM and the earth comes in front of the sun at 6:00 AM.

    So when a earth comes in contact with the sun, the light emitted by the sun at 5:52 AM reaches the earth at 6:00. This happens constantly.

    Another example is of the scientist working at NASA. When they observe some pictures then this pictures are also old. Some of these pictures are those of the remains of the Big Bang.

    The picture of engulfing of Sun by a Black Hole reaches the telescope far later as it takes time for light to travel such long distance.

    參考資料: smithjack1967.blogspot.com
  • 10 年前

    No, considering the distances involved are hugely different and that you can't react quickly enough to notice a 'speed' of light. Can you accurately and precisely measure the time taken for the light photons to travel from one point to another? No, this can only be done with highly precise and expensive equipment found in research laboratories. (Or using telescope and positions of planets but this is much less precise). The light that we see is actually millions of years old since it takes that long for light emitted from fusion in the Sun's core to reach the outside. However it takes 8 minutes to reach the Earth once it has left the Sun's surface.

    The speed of light is a fundamental constant in Physics and is equal to

    299 792 458 m / s. This stays the same everywhere according to Special Relativity no matter how quickly something is already traveling. So no, the speed of light doesn't vary with the light source.

  • Relief
    Lv 4
    10 年前

    The speed of light has nothing to do with the sizes of objects but distance only. The fact is, even when you do your experiment in your room the scales stand the same, it does take time for light to travel from the flashlight to the sun model, it's just that the distance is too short for light that you can't identify how many billionths of a second it took to travel that distance, but the distance from sun to earth is enough for you to realize how much time it took, the distance between the sun and earth is about 90 million miles

  • 匿名使用者
    10 年前

    "isn't it obvious that it takes no time for the light of that lamp to hit the sun" - no, its not obvious.

    If light takes 8.3 minutes to travel the distance between the sun and the Earth, why would it matter which direction it was moving - it would still take 8.3 minutes.

    Your idea of a model doesn't work, because the distance between the objects in your model are so small that light appears to travel that tiny distance instantaneously.

    The ratio of distances doesn't matter, any model that is small enough to set up on Earth (even on a football field for example) is still such a small distance that the time for the light to travel is too short for you to measure.

    Its a real shame they don't teach any basic science in schools anymore...

  • 10 年前

    The speed of light is 299,792,458 metres per second, or approximately 186,282 miles per second. You're used to light being seen as instantaneous because you're entire life you've experienced it on a tiny scale. (Turning on a flashlight). It's like if you shot a bullet at something five feet away. It'd appear to arrive at the target instantly. However, if you were to shoot at something very far away, you would realize the time it takes for the bullet to travel. Keep in mind the earth is about 150 million km from the sun.

    參考資料: my own head. a little wikipedia
還有問題?馬上發問,尋求解答。